Commercial Dilapidations: A Landlord's Complete Guide

Commercial dilapidations can result in significant financial claims when business leases end. Kent Surveyors provide specialist dilapidations services for landlords and tenants across Maidstone, Ashford, Canterbury and throughout Kent. Our RICS chartered surveyors prepare comprehensive schedules of dilapidations, negotiate settlements, and protect your commercial property investment. Understanding the dilapidations process helps landlords recover repair costs and tenants minimize their liabilities.

What Are Commercial Dilapidations?

Dilapidations refer to breaches of lease covenants related to the repair, maintenance, decoration, and reinstatement of commercial property. When tenants fail to comply with their lease obligations, landlords can claim compensation for the cost of putting the property back into the required condition.

Kent Surveyors explain that dilapidations claims arise from three main lease obligations:

• Repair covenants: Tenant's duty to maintain and repair the property
• Decoration covenants: Requirements to decorate internally and externally
• Reinstatement/alterations covenants: Removing tenant's alterations and restoring original layout

Most commercial leases in Kent contain Full Repairing and Insuring (FRI) clauses, making tenants responsible for all repairs, maintenance, and insurance costs. Understanding your lease obligations is crucial for both landlords and tenants.

Types of Dilapidations Schedules

Interim Schedule of Dilapidations

Kent Surveyors prepare interim schedules during the lease term to notify tenants of accumulating breaches. Benefits include:

• Allowing tenants time to complete repairs voluntarily
• Preventing dilapidations worsening over time
• Demonstrating good estate management
• Avoiding large end-of-lease disputes

Landlords typically serve interim schedules 2-3 years before lease expiry. Tenants who address issues early often save money compared to terminal claims.

Terminal Schedule of Dilapidations

Terminal schedules are served at or shortly after lease end, detailing all breaches of lease covenants. Kent Surveyors' terminal schedules include:

• Detailed description of each breach
• Specific lease clause the breach relates to
• Cost of remedying each breach
• Photographic evidence
• Professional fees (surveyor and legal costs)

These comprehensive schedules form the basis for negotiating settlements. Accurate cost assessments are crucial - over-inflated claims can backfire under the Dilapidations Protocol.

Quantified Demand

If tenants don't respond to the terminal schedule or dispute the claim, landlords issue a Quantified Demand - a formal monetary claim under the Dilapidations Protocol. This document must include:

• The terminal schedule with costs
• Diminution valuation (actual financial loss to landlord)
• Comparison showing claim is reasonable
• Evidence justifying the claim amount

The Quantified Demand creates a formal 56-day negotiation period before litigation can commence.

The Dilapidations Protocol

The Dilapidations Protocol (effective January 2012) is a Pre-Action Protocol designed to encourage early settlement without litigation. Kent Surveyors guide clients through this process:

Key Protocol Requirements:

1. Schedule of Dilapidations: Landlord serves detailed schedule (ideally within 56 days of lease end)
2. Tenant's Response: Tenant has reasonable time to respond (typically 56 days)
3. Quantified Demand: If unresolved, landlord issues formal monetary claim with diminution valuation
4. Negotiation Period: Both parties negotiate in good faith for 56 days
5. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR): Parties should consider mediation before litigation
6. Court Proceedings: Only as last resort if settlement fails

Kent Surveyors help clients comply with the Protocol, which courts expect parties to follow. Non-compliance can result in cost penalties even if you win your case.

Common Dilapidation Items in Kent Commercial Properties

1. Internal Decorations

Most leases require redecoration at specified intervals or at lease end. Common issues:

• Faded or marked paintwork
• Damaged wall coverings
• Stained ceilings
• Poor quality tenant decorations

Typical Costs: Internal redecoration £15-£30 per square meter for offices, £10-£20 for warehouses. Total costs for 2,000 sq ft office: £3,000-£6,000.

2. Floor Coverings

• Worn or damaged carpets
• Damaged raised access floors
• Stained or broken floor tiles
• Warehouse floor damage

Typical Costs: Carpet tiles £20-£40 per square meter installed. Resin floor repairs £30-£60 per square meter. Full warehouse floor replacement £40-£80 per square meter.

3. Mechanical & Electrical Services

• Failed or inadequately maintained heating systems
• Faulty air conditioning units
• Lighting failures and emergency lighting defects
• Electrical installation testing not up to date

Typical Costs: Boiler replacement £3,000-£8,000. Air conditioning repairs/replacement £2,000-£15,000+. Electrical testing and remedial works £1,000-£5,000.

4. External Repairs

• Roof leaks and failed coverings
• Cracked or damaged rendering
• Failed window seals and broken glazing
• Damaged cladding
• Car park surface deterioration

Typical Costs: Roof repairs £50-£150 per square meter. External redecoration £20-£40 per square meter. Window repairs £200-£800 per window. Car park resurfacing £30-£60 per square meter.

5. Reinstatement of Alterations

Tenants must remove unauthorized alterations and restore premises to original condition unless the lease permits retention. Common reinstatement works:

• Removing mezzanine floors
• Reinstating removed partition walls
• Removing tenant's signage
• Restoring original kitchen/toilet layouts
• Making good after removal of tenant's fixtures

Typical Costs: Highly variable. Mezzanine removal £5,000-£20,000. Partition reinstatement £100-£200 per linear meter. Full office re-configuration £50-£100 per square meter.

The Role of Diminution Valuation

Since the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, landlords' dilapidations claims cannot exceed the reduction in property value (diminution) caused by the breaches. Kent Surveyors explain that diminution valuations are crucial in dilapidations disputes.

What Is Diminution?

Diminution is the difference in the property's market value:

• Value in disrepair (actual condition at lease end)
• Versus value in repair (compliant with lease obligations)

If the landlord plans immediate redevelopment or the property will be re-let "as is," diminution may be minimal or zero, potentially capping the dilapidations claim significantly.

Supersession

Supersession occurs when planned works would remedy the dilapidation breaches anyway. For example:

• Landlord plans full refurbishment making redecoration claims superseded
• Demolition planned making all repair claims superseded
• Significant alterations rendering some breaches irrelevant

Kent Surveyors' diminution valuations properly account for landlords' intentions, ensuring claims are reasonable and defensible. Over-inflated claims face significant reductions during negotiations or at trial.

Landlords' Guide to Maximizing Dilapidations Recovery

1. Start Early - Serve Interim Schedules

Don't wait until lease end. Serve interim schedules 2-3 years before expiry. This:

• Gives tenants time to remedy breaches voluntarily
• Prevents deterioration worsening
• Demonstrates good estate management
• Strengthens your position if disputes arise

2. Document Everything

Kent Surveyors recommend comprehensive photographic evidence:

• Schedule of condition at lease start
• Regular inspection photographs during tenancy
• Detailed photography at lease end
• Date-stamped evidence of all breaches

Good documentation prevents "he said, she said" disputes about the property condition.

3. Be Realistic About Claims

Over-inflated claims backfire under the Dilapidations Protocol. Kent Surveyors prepare realistic schedules that:

• Include only genuine breaches of lease covenants
• Use accurate cost estimates based on market rates
• Consider diminution from the outset
• Account for the property's intended future use

4. Act Quickly

Serve terminal schedules within 56 days of lease end. Delays weaken your position and can result in cost penalties if litigation proceeds.

5. Consider Settlement Pragmatically

Litigation is expensive and uncertain. Most dilapidations disputes settle for 40-70% of the original claim. Kent Surveyors help landlords assess:

• Strength of the claim versus defenses
• Cost of litigation versus settlement offers
• Business relationship considerations
• Time and management resources required for disputes

Tenants' Guide to Minimizing Dilapidations Liability

1. Understand Your Lease Obligations

At lease start, Kent Surveyors recommend tenants:

• Carefully review repair and decoration covenants
• Understand what "good repair" means in your lease context
• Negotiate schedule of condition to limit repair obligations
• Document the property's condition at lease start

2. Keep on Top of Repairs

Ongoing maintenance is cheaper than terminal dilapidations:

• Address minor repairs promptly before they worsen
• Maintain proper records of repairs completed
• Conduct regular inspections
• Budget for terminal redecoration and repairs from the outset

3. Respond to Interim Schedules Properly

If you receive an interim schedule:

• Instruct your own surveyor to review it
• Challenge any unreasonable items
• Complete agreed works voluntarily (often cheaper)
• Don't ignore it - issues won't disappear

4. Challenge Terminal Schedules Appropriately

When you receive a terminal schedule, Kent Surveyors acting for tenants assess:

• Whether claimed breaches are genuine
• If costs are reasonable (often inflated 20-40%)
• Diminution arguments
• Supersession by landlord's intended works
• Whether items were in this condition at lease start

5. Consider Early Settlement

Legal costs escalate quickly. Settling at 50-60% of a reasonable claim early may be more cost-effective than protracted negotiations and litigation.

Scott Schedules

When parties can't agree, disputes often progress to Scott Schedules - comparative tables showing:

Scott Schedules clarify areas of agreement and disagreement, facilitating settlement or providing structure for court proceedings. Kent Surveyors prepare detailed Scott Schedules that clearly present your position.

Typical Dilapidations Costs in Kent

Dilapidations claims vary enormously based on property type, size, and condition. Kent Surveyors provide indicative costs:

Small Office (1,000 sq ft):

• Well-maintained property: £5,000-£15,000
• Poorly maintained: £15,000-£35,000
• Significant reinstatement required: £35,000-£70,000+

Medium Office (5,000 sq ft):

• Well-maintained: £15,000-£40,000
• Poorly maintained: £40,000-£100,000
• Significant reinstatement: £100,000-£250,000+

Industrial Unit (10,000 sq ft):

• Well-maintained: £20,000-£50,000
• Poorly maintained: £50,000-£150,000
• Significant reinstatement: £150,000-£400,000+

Retail Unit (High Street):

• Well-maintained: £10,000-£30,000
• Poorly maintained: £30,000-£80,000
• Full shop-front and interior works: £80,000-£200,000+

These are guideline figures. Actual claims depend on specific lease terms, property condition, and landlords' future intentions.

Professional Fees

Dilapidations disputes involve significant professional costs:

Surveyor Fees:

• Terminal schedule preparation: £2,000-£8,000
• Tenant's response/Scott Schedule: £2,000-£6,000
• Expert witness services: £3,000-£15,000+

Legal Fees:

• Pre-litigation advice and correspondence: £3,000-£10,000
• Full litigation to trial: £30,000-£100,000+ per party

These costs often drive settlement negotiations. A £50,000 dilapidations claim might cost £40,000-£60,000 to litigate, making settlement at £30,000 attractive to both parties.

← Back to Blog